Lack of data prohibits evaluation of legislative impacts
(Washington, DC) – According to a new study released by The Council of State Governments (CSG), in collaboration with the Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries (ISRI), there is an insufficient tracking of metal theft data needed to properly analyze the effect of new state laws aimed at reducing the crime. During the 2013-14 legislative sessions, there were more than 220 bills introduced with the goal of stopping metals theft, with 51 being passed into law. Given the many variations in the laws, researchers set out to determine which, if any, were effective in reducing crime.
“All 50 states have laws on the books dealing with metal theft crimes and all have differing regulations, requirements, penalties, and other variables,” said Robin Wiener, president of ISRI. “New laws and regulations are often the result of political reactions to high-profile crimes without any real analysis of how to address the crime as a whole. To solve this, the scrap recycling industry sought to find out if crime rates could shed any light on what laws seem to work best when it came to reducing the crime of metals theft. Armed with this knowledge, we can work with state legislatures to pass more effective legislation.”
The CSG researchers found that the lack of metal theft crime data was due to the following reasons:
- There are no states that comprehensively and uniformly track the number of metal thefts;
- Current data is “insufficient to accurately reflect the true rate of metal theft for purposes of state-level analysis;” and
- The “quality and accuracy” of available local data cannot be verified for statistical review.
“The study shows the immense need for a uniform method to track metals theft crimes, arrests, and prosecution,” said Wiener. “Once in place, policymakers will have a much more accurate picture of this serious problem facing communities across the country and how to address it. The recycling industry looks forward to working closely with all stakeholders to best accomplish this task so the most effective types of legislation can be enacted in the states.”
ISRI uses a variety of innovative partnerships and technology in its efforts to be part of the solution when it comes to fighting metal theft. Earlier this year, it formed the Materials Theft Law Enforcement Advisory Council, a select group of experienced law enforcement officers, prosecutors and security personnel from around the country. The council advises ISRI on programming and resources it can offer to the law enforcement community and will play an integral role in the determining the best way to collect the data needed on metal theft.
ISRI also recently launched an upgraded version of ScrapTheftAlert.com, a free tool for law enforcement that allows police to alert the scrap industry of significant thefts of materials in the United States and Canada. Upon validation and review, alerts are broadcast by email to all subscribed users within a 100 mile radius of where the incident occurred. The system boasts more than 17,000 active users and has recovered nearly $1.4 million in stolen property.
A copy of the full study can be found on the CSG website.
###
The Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries, Inc. (ISRI) is the Voice of the Recycling Industry™. ISRI represents more than 1,600 companies in 21 chapters nationwide that process, broker and industrially consume scrap commodities, including metals, paper, plastics, glass, rubber, electronics and textiles. With headquarters in Washington, DC, the Institute provides safety, education, advocacy, and compliance training, and promotes public awareness of the vital role recycling plays in the U.S. economy, global trade, the environment and sustainable development.